What a Website Redesign Actually Costs for Montana Nonprofits & Small Businesses

Why “Website Cost” Is a Hard Question (and Why That’s Normal)

“How much does a website cost?” is one of the most common and most confusing questions clients ask.

The reason it’s hard to answer isn’t because designers are being vague. It’s because a website isn’t a single product. It’s a scope-based project, shaped by your goals, content, and functionality needs.

That’s also why many designers offer both packages and custom projects: they serve different levels of clarity and complexity.

Typical Website Redesign Ranges

Rather than a single number, website projects usually fall into ranges based on complexity:

Entry-level / starter websites – Begin at $4,200
Best for organizations with clear content and straightforward needs. These are often well-suited to packages.

Mid-range redesigns – Range between $6,500–$12,000
Ideal for organizations that need stronger structure, strategy, and flexibility.

Larger or more complex websites – Often exceed $12,000
These often include many pages, multiple stakeholders, or custom functionality and require more planning and coordination.

Before answering “How much does a website cost?”, designers usually ask a different question:
What does your website need to support?

What Actually Affects Website Cost (a.k.a. the Scope)

Number of Pages (Project Size)

More pages mean more layouts, development, and testing. A smaller, well-organized site can often be more effective, but page count still affects scope.

Special Features & Functionality

All websites include core elements like text, images, video, navigation, and basic forms.

Anything beyond that is considered custom functionality, such as:

  • booking or scheduling tools
  • membership or login areas
  • advanced forms or workflows
  • third-party integrations

(These features require additional planning and development, which increases scope.)

SEO & Site Structure

SEO impacts scope primarily during planning. Projects that include intentional page structure, hierarchy, and search visibility require more upfront strategy but tend to perform better long-term.

Photography & Visual Assets

Custom photography or coordinated visual planning adds time and value compared to using existing or stock imagery alone.

Timeline Expectations

Shorter timelines often require more focused scheduling and fewer revision cycles. Firm timelines should be discussed early to either plan for or avoid rush fees.

What’s Included — and What’s Not

Website Packages

Packages are designed to provide clarity and predictability.

They typically include:

  • a defined number of pages
  • integration of text, images, and video
  • responsive design
  • standard forms
  • basic SEO setup

They do not automatically include advanced features like booking systems, memberships, or custom integrations. Those are scoped separately if needed.

Custom Packages

Custom projects are tailored to your specific needs. Everything included (and not included) is clearly outlined up front based on scope.

Homepage design for the Western Apicultural Society featuring a beekeeper holding a honeycomb frame, highlighting membership benefits, educational events, and beekeeping resources across the western U.S.

When You Might Not Be Ready for a Redesign

A website redesign works best when it’s supporting something stable.

You may want to pause or clarify first if:

  • your services or offerings are still changing
  • internal decisions haven’t been settled
  • the goals for your website aren’t yet clear

In those cases, clarifying content or direction first often leads to a stronger, more effective redesign later.

How to Think About ROI (Realistically)

For some, a website functions as a trusted reference point. It’s a place to send people who already know about the organization. For others, the goal is visibility: being found by new audiences through search.

Both are valid but they work differently.

Many people expect a website to bring in clients, often meaning improved SEO and discoverability. While a well-structured website absolutely supports this, it’s important to understand that SEO is a long-term strategy, not an instant switch.

A successful site:

  • clearly explains what you do
  • builds trust with the right audience
  • supports referrals
  • saves time internally

But it does not operate in isolation.

Search performance is influenced by:

  • content quality
  • site structure
  • consistency over time
  • how well a site aligns with what people are actually searching for

For most organizations, the real return on a website is cumulative. Over time, it becomes a reliable reference point, a foundation for ongoing SEO efforts, and a support system for referrals and outreach.

When expectations are aligned with how websites actually function, they tend to deliver far more value and far less frustration.

A Simple Next Step

If this overview helped clarify how website cost is shaped by scope, complexity, and readiness — great. You may already be closer to requesting pricing than you thought.

If you’re still unsure where your project lands, that’s completely normal. In many cases, uncertainty around cost is a signal that goals or direction need to be clarified before moving forward.

If you’d like help working through that, you’re welcome to reach out to inquire about a website strategy session: a dedicated working session designed to clarify direction, define scope, and determine the right path forward before discussing pricing.

Website Strategy Session

Not sure where your website project lands yet? A website strategy session is a dedicated working session designed to clarify direction, define scope, and determine the right path forward before discussing pricing.

If you’re still sorting out goals, internal alignment, or readiness, this session helps establish a clear foundation for next steps.

Clear direction leads to clearer expectations, more accurate estimates, and better long-term outcomes.

Next Post
Do You Need Professional Photography for Your Website?
Previous Post
6 False SEO Beliefs